獸醫師撞成尿失禁 中友 電梯公司判賠

作者: Dorra (朵拉) 看板: Gossiping
標題: Re: [新聞] 獸醫師撞成尿失禁　中友 電梯公司判賠
時間: Wed May  2 17:06:56 2012


代po，委託者權限不足



=====代po分隔線========


我當時有目擊整個發生過程


當天我和那個當事人的確都沒看到小孩子有按緊急按鈕，只有看到有小朋友

恰好站在扶梯口的兩側，當時我去服務台通報中友電扶梯停止有人受傷，不

知道是不是小孩子所為，但中友卻把小孩子和大人放走後，說她們都有監視

器可以調閱，要求當事者自行搭計程車去醫院，他們不願意現在協助處理，

結果就和當事者發生爭論，後來過了半小時才有主管來處理，當時我本身也

有輕微受傷，就跟當事者、中友客服一同去急診的時候，中友明明告訴我們

已經調閱監視器有眉目了，叫我和那個當事者不要緊張，但因為我傷勢比較

輕微，所以就作罷沒有跟中友追消息下去。



後來被法院叫去當證人的時候，我也很驚訝，中友居然說已經把監視器洗掉，

連讓我或者當事者看都沒看過，而且全程把過錯都推給小孩子和受傷的當事

者，可是明明當時我自己也不確定是不是小孩子按，我也都沒看到小孩子有

蹲下去按壓的動作，而且我當時剛好是側身在當事者的附近階梯，我絕對可

以作證他有緊握扶手！而且沒有像中友誣賴他的在講電話！他連手扶梯停了

之後，手都還緊抓著耶！但我看他人整個往後攤靠在扶手，臉色整個發白，

一直痛到哀哀叫，說他的腰和屁股撞得很痛，而且後來聽說他手開刀攣縮，

沒握的話會如此嗎？我所說的一切，都在法院出庭筆錄有記載，絕對願意負

擔法律責任！



這判決我只能說，當事人才是最大的受害者，請大家不要再說中友和電梯公

司很無辜了，身為當天在場者，很多辛酸不是外人所懂，我很慶幸我只有輕

傷，不需像當事者打官司，也不用遭中友和電梯公司的很多惡意傷害，如果

大家都在現場，就會知道當事者卻要負擔四成責任，中友和富士達電梯的律

師真的很厲害。



一審的時候，我也有看到這新聞，那時候我還是很不懂為什麼中友要這麼極

力推給小孩，卻又不舉證到底小孩在哪呢？把小孩子揪出來痛扁一頓，然後

責任都是小孩和父母負擔，不是很好嗎？後來看到一篇ｍｏｂｉｌｅ的討論

（請服用 http://5i01.com/topicdetail.php?f=37&t=2183719&p=36　），

我忽然懂了！原來只要業者賴給第三人，那他們就有機會減輕責任，而且很

可能當時真的不是小孩子按了，而是忽然剛好碰巧故障，只是那兩個小屁孩

剛好倒楣站在扶梯口被誤會了，所以業者只要死咬著是有小屁孩按，然後又

說小屁孩跑掉了，這樣就會像現在結果他們根本不用負擔全責，那個當事者

卻反而要負擔四成。


所以中友百貨和電梯業者真的很可憐嗎？知道事實的人就不會這麼說了。



順帶一提，看到新聞畫面，中友示範給新聞媒體拍攝電扶梯按壓緊急停止後

有緩衝時間？當時我可是整個從二樓衝好幾階梯快到快一樓，真不知道該慶

幸自己運動細胞好，往下衝有即時像大鵬鳥一樣展翅穩住嗎？而且，新聞畫

面所有緊急按扭也跟我當天目擊不一樣，當天是英文字縮寫 EMER STOP，而

且是放置倒反，也沒有什麼壓克力片覆蓋，出入口也沒有依法貼任何警告標

示啦！早就都改過了。( ′-`)y-～



我看討論區有人問，為什麼沒有依法張貼他們檢驗會合格？這其中祕辛，就

又是另一個故事了......



--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 114.39.144.195
推 showmermb:幫高調                                                05/02 17:09
推 dryweed:有掛有推                                                05/02 17:09
推 ladykin:快推爆幫當事人                                          05/02 17:09
推 LaBoLa:八卦板回來啦~~~                                          05/02 17:10
推 way0963:高調                                                    05/02 17:10
推 smalldra:有真相有推                                             05/02 17:10
推 berice152233:高調                                               05/02 17:10
推 jamesyu545:                           Dorra~ 我愛妳             05/02 17:10
推 iori325:真八卦推一個                                            05/02 17:10
推 philip1205:基八死財團不意外                                     05/02 17:12
推 noei:不推不行了.中國之友不意外                                  05/02 17:12
推 GoodMemory:推 這事件好久前看過 那獸醫師真得很慘 好好的未來      05/02 17:12
推 cyp001:不推不行 這才是八卦                                      05/02 17:12
推 clvf:推推                                                       05/02 17:13
→ GoodMemory:都被這過失摧毀了                                     05/02 17:13
推 saintmagic:好八卦                                               05/02 17:13
推 aids1234:幫高調！中友踹共                                       05/02 17:13
推 maxxV3:推                                                       05/02 17:13
→ maxxV3:為啥有握住手扶 卻反而更嚴重(開刀尿失禁)??                05/02 17:14
推 armkira:推 高調高調                                             05/02 17:14
推 Mopipi:幹 阿扁下台                                              05/02 17:14
推 MadStanley:                                                     05/02 17:14
推 forpeople:推真相 這一篇文章值 187 Ptt幣 所以你借你朋友帳號?     05/02 17:15
推 bravee:幫高調(快上訴)                                           05/02 17:15
推 wild2012:摔到尾椎 造成下半身癱瘓 絕對是有可能的!                05/02 17:15
推 spook:推                                                        05/02 17:17
推 GunsNRoses:中天水準 不意外                                      05/02 17:17
推 KINGTIGERX:高調                                                 05/02 17:18
推 QQgirlQQQ:陰森記者快來抄                                        05/02 17:18
推 scarface:八卦活了!!!!                                           05/02 17:18
→ dlevel:wiki說中友是台灣營業額前三的百貨耶，那為何還會有財務危   05/02 17:18
推 wjv:gj                                                          05/02 17:18
推 shadowppt:還真八卦  科科!!!                                     05/02 17:19
→ dlevel:機，是要被掏空烙跑的前兆嗎？                             05/02 17:19
推 mankaro:!!!!                                                    05/02 17:19
推 axzs1111:快抄阿                                                 05/02 17:19
推 coldone:推dlevel 他們老闆劉福壽洗錢掏空啦!之前有新聞有說被判刑  05/02 17:19
推 wawa1109:                                                       05/02 17:20
推 abine:幫高調                                                    05/02 17:20
推 morgan13:財團真的不是普通的混蛋 幫高調                          05/02 17:20
推 littlenee:e04                                                   05/02 17:21
推 wooshi:幫高調!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!                                  05/02 17:21
推 XSZX:幫高調                                                     05/02 17:21
推 lenjoyn:幫高調                                                  05/02 17:23
推 coldone:董事長換劉福壽的老婆,李琦玲（新聞曾說劉是王又曾第二）   05/02 17:23
推 leon7777:幫高調                                                 05/02 17:24
推 s2678132:高調                                                   05/02 17:24
推 momoko51244:有真相給推                                          05/02 17:24
→ s2678132:還好我都不逛中友                                       05/02 17:25
推 turbomons:高調                                                  05/02 17:25
推 DM1984:幫推 抵制他                                              05/02 17:25
推 inyei:                                                          05/02 17:26
推 st8602200:wow～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～～   05/02 17:26
推 hellheavn:幫高調                                                05/02 17:26
推 potota92000:八卦模範生                                          05/02 17:26
推 dmlin0120:幫幫                                                  05/02 17:27
推 s32635:這才是八卦版嘛                                           05/02 17:27
推 ja781028:快抄阿                                                 05/02 17:27
推 tokyoto:中友要賴給小孩 又自己把監視畫面洗掉 那就應該責任通吃吧  05/02 17:28
推 iMANIA:幫高調                                                   05/02 17:28
推 headcase:有真相推一個 這間百貨真是有擔當啊                      05/02 17:28
→ tokyoto:這不就變成湮滅證據了？                                  05/02 17:28

(代PO)

他們當庭是說，因為已經超過半年了，所以沒有保留，被洗掉了
（這樣算不算湮滅證物我也不知道）

我只是很驚訝，正常人都知道要保留影片，怎麼他們卻不保留？

但是後來聽說他們又有改說法，改成什麼我就不知道了，

但是我確定他們就是沒拿出來當天監視畫面

推 k145:幫高調...                                                  05/02 17:29
推 sky6969:高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高調  05/02 17:30
推 BLACKLAGOON:幫高調                                              05/02 17:30
→ sky6969:高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高調  05/02 17:31
→ sky6969:高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高調  05/02 17:31
→ sky6969:高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高調  05/02 17:31
推 darkelecy:高調                                                  05/02 17:31
→ sky6969:高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高調  05/02 17:31
推 VVax:                                                           05/02 17:31
→ sky6969:高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高高調  05/02 17:31
推 TRUE5566:八卦清流                                               05/02 17:31
推 Sauvignon:原來這才是真相                                        05/02 17:32
推 miboo:!!!!!!!!!                                                 05/02 17:33
推 ascii:@_@                                                       05/02 17:34
推 mexxxxem:八卦回來了推                                           05/02 17:34
推 joesoul:                                                        05/02 17:34
推 coldone:我記得之前巴哈,好像當事者朋友還有寫到中友還反告獸醫說   05/02 17:34
推 Subaudition:這才是八卦 推一個!                                  05/02 17:35
→ coldone:害他們營運困難,但是被法院駁回,是嗎？                    05/02 17:35
推 s2678132:潮潮潮朝潮朝潮朝                                       05/02 17:36
推 anedo:幫高調                                                    05/02 17:36
推 cashliu:中yo貌似很不負責喔                                      05/02 17:36
推 daru:幫高調!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!                       05/02 17:36
推 icq7584:八卦!!!                                                 05/02 17:37
→ nicso:醫生沒治好要不要賠?                                       05/02 17:37
推 AI3767:破壞證物不知有罪否 ?                                     05/02 17:39
推 akiottm:有八卦有推!                                             05/02 17:39
推 deadalus:高調                                                   05/02 17:40
推 ferrinatice:八卦復活了                                          05/02 17:40
推 ga045213:推!!!!!!!!!!!!!!幫高調調調調調調調!!!!!!!!!!!          05/02 17:41
→ coldone:法官這樣對中友是仁至義盡,中友和電梯公司賺到了喔^.<      05/02 17:42
→ coldone:要是在國外,這事情業者就吃不了兜著走了吧                 05/02 17:42
推 p3:幫高調.....                                                  05/02 17:43
推 busters0:記者還不快抄                                           05/02 17:44
推 bjtctp:高調!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!                                      05/02 17:44
推 kawa0710:幫推上新聞                                             05/02 17:44
推 minilovesong:幫高調                                             05/02 17:46
推 johnkimo:push!!                                                 05/02 17:48
推 veger9500:幫高調!!                                              05/02 17:48
推 needhp:幫高調!!!!                                               05/02 17:53
推 longdog:推                                                      05/02 17:55
推 mc12355:幫高調  果然在台灣裝死就能賴掉很多事情                  05/02 17:55
推 debian99:高調推                                                 05/02 17:57
推 lisy1991516:                                                    05/02 17:58
推 samcool:如果是真的  那真的是垃圾                                05/02 17:59
推 sheepxo:有卦友推!                                               05/02 17:59
推 nkanka2020:中友的員工應該都隱隱擔心吧  公司財務不穩…           05/02 18:00
推 kyukyu:悲哀的台灣法律                                           05/02 18:00
→ nkanka2020:他們有很多都很資深的員工都很認真工作                 05/02 18:01
推 chungyiju:                                                      05/02 18:01
推 syu72:幫高調                                                    05/02 18:01
推 kyhkyh:幫高調                                                   05/02 18:02
推 vi000246:記者抄的話會被中友搞死吧 只能算當事人衰了              05/02 18:02
推 g09130931:推一個!!!                                             05/02 18:04
推 gll:當事人為何要負四成啊                                        05/02 18:05
推 ERQQ:!!!!!!!!!!!!!                                              05/02 18:05
推 ichup:八卦又回來了 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  05/02 18:07
推 chingfish:推!幫高調                                             05/02 18:07
推 howshaw:八卦活了!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!                     05/02 18:09
推 forme:真八卦                                                    05/02 18:09
推 harukak:                                                        05/02 18:11
推 heroe:那些年，那些事，那些人，操！                              05/02 18:11
推 jackfuck:有掛有推                                               05/02 18:13
推 a246811:                                                        05/02 18:13
推 inzoo10:真八卦                                                  05/02 18:13
推 TSbb:台灣人可悲的地方就是不確定事實前，寧願先選擇酸弱勢一方     05/02 18:14
推 BuzzStyle:高調啊!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!                           05/02 18:14
→ TSbb:然後一副中立立場的高姿態口吻，例如下面鴻海哥vxlxyxix       05/02 18:15
推 xdbx:11111                                                      05/02 18:15
推 yuhurefu:幫高調 好爛                                            05/02 18:17
推 smileray:!!!!!!!!!!!!!!　                                       05/02 18:17
推 mcshang:真八卦 推                                               05/02 18:17
推 hqu:有錢有勢  法律為你服務   沒錢沒勢就準備吃屎                 05/02 18:18
推 justice00s:高調                                                 05/02 18:19
推 qw75393:幫高調                                                  05/02 18:20
推 chi0425:果然真的有掛                                            05/02 18:20
推 glory5566:真是可怕啊 我都被新聞誤導了                           05/02 18:20
推 radi035:八卦又活了                                              05/02 18:21
推 jack8759:以前常去中友,跟奸商賺到錢懊悔不已                      05/02 18:21
推 jordan621:幫高調                                                05/02 18:21
推 mark89:反正台灣的法院跟法官  唉  大家也知道是怎麼一回事吧       05/02 18:22
推 glory5566:不過我覺得FB轉貼爆卦比較有用                          05/02 18:25
推 kazake:幫高調                                                   05/02 18:26
推 parkerlived:高 調                                               05/02 18:26
推 OrzJ:幫高調                                                     05/02 18:26
推 assyrian:幫高調                                                 05/02 18:29
推 widec:這樣湮滅證據真是垃圾                                      05/02 18:31
推 smallfat0930:HIGH                                               05/02 18:32
推 bestbeauty:幫高調                                               05/02 18:32
推 vcsue:幫                                                        05/02 18:34
推 fooioi:推                                                       05/02 18:37
推 DALUGI:推                                                       05/02 18:39
推 acer758219:有掛有推                                             05/02 18:41
推 acookie:推! 高調                                                05/02 18:42
推 pp617:...                                                       05/02 18:43
推 smallx3:                                                        05/02 18:44
推 Boyzone:cc                                                      05/02 18:46
→ lulocke:按與否  到底是什麼意思  ???                             05/02 18:50

已改白話一些。

意思就是，不知道小朋友到底有沒有按

推 tony77998:八卦板清流                                            05/02 18:51
推 JerryGreen:幫                                                   05/02 18:54
※ 編輯: Dorra           來自: 114.39.144.195       (05/02 19:01)
推 ddos:小孩按電梯的舉證責任不在中友那方嗎  洗掉不就對中友不利?    05/02 18:59
推 demonfish:所以是電梯自己故障要嫁禍給小孩嗎@o@?!                 05/02 19:01
→ coldone:樓上沒看清楚文章 看完就知道中友幹嘛不提供啦             05/02 19:01
→ coldone:阿阿阿 是樓樓上 我是說ddos啦                            05/02 19:02
推 ddos:是為了誣賴醫生在打電話?                                    05/02 19:04
推 lb00202549:中友拒絕往來戶!!!                                    05/02 19:05
→ coldone:痾@@ 都可以誣賴吧?反正沒了監視器,他愛說怎樣都可以啊     05/02 19:06
推 ZOONADIA:                                                       05/02 19:06
→ coldone:甚至可以說那個獸醫在電扶梯上翻跟斗也可以?(誤很大        05/02 19:06
推 fakeayumi:以前很喜歡中友的說..以後不去了!!                      05/02 19:07
推 colatea:有卦有推 希望傷者早日恢復健康                           05/02 19:08
推 power3641:幫高調                                                05/02 19:10
推 naturalQa:這才是八卦版阿  正義 善良 都回來了～                  05/02 19:10
推 jonse:有掛有推                                                  05/02 19:19
推 Abric:                                                          05/02 19:20
推 lovelovefree:以後誰還敢在中友搭手扶梯呀～看來去之前先燒香拜拜   05/02 19:21
推 gmoz:幹....                                                     05/02 19:24
推 poister:推                                                      05/02 19:27
推 albb0920:推!                                                    05/02 19:29
推 ahonchen:不推不是人                                             05/02 19:39
推 xufunny:八卦板復活了!!!                                         05/02 19:43
推 mofeather:這就是八卦                                            05/02 19:43
→ xufunny:獸醫師可以調通聯記錄證明自己當時沒打電話                05/02 19:44
→ xufunny:中油就算指證獸醫打電話 自己也要負舉證責任吧             05/02 19:44
噓 tosay:紅明顯,你以為記者會來平反嗎.。棵棵..記者的薪水是??        05/02 19:46
推 littlenee:記者趕抄我請樓下吃雞排                                05/02 19:47
推 memalina:幫高調                                                 05/02 19:48
推 horse175:記者快來抄                                             05/02 19:48
噓 bztfir:幹 記者快抄啊                                            05/02 19:50
推 Malkovich:八卦精神!!                                            05/02 19:51
推 ly4138:                                                         05/02 19:54
推 optimisticss:                                                   05/02 19:54
推 Yie:                                                            05/02 20:07
推 octopuz:推推 !!!                                                05/02 20:13
推 Asucks:！！！！！！！！！！！                                   05/02 20:17
推 chienk:超過分的                                                 05/02 20:28
推 housemale:台灣法律都保護壞人跟有錢人的你不知道嗎?窮人等死!      05/02 20:33
推 rinsoukan:高調囉                                                05/02 20:36
噓 satotatsuya:記者哩                                              05/02 20:37
推 mjonask:八卦不死!!!!!!!!!!!!!                                   05/02 20:38
推 dillon80326:沒用的，妓者根本不敢來抄這篇                        05/02 20:47
推 blahblah:推                                                     05/02 20:53
推 AdPiG:中友的設備真的是全台中百貨公司最爛!!!                     05/02 21:00
推 easan:記者來爆!!!                                               05/02 21:41
推 PREE8833:幫高調!!!                                              05/02 22:03
推 darkofpolo:記者快來                                             05/02 22:15
推 Refauth:路過必推                                                05/02 22:26